| 1. | Fr. Carmel Vassallo of the Child Jesus | 1896 |
| 2. | Fr. Angelo Darmanin of the Mother of God | 1903 |
| 3. | Fr. Eliseus Caruana of St Francis | 1909 |
| 4. | Fr. Albert M. Giacomotto of Jesus the Nazarene | 1915 |
| 5. | Fr. Carmel Vassallo of the Child Jesus | 1918 |
| 6. | Fr. Redemptus Camilleri of the Cross | 1924 |
| 7. | Fr. Carmel Vassallo of the Child Jesus | 1928 |
| 8. | Fr. Eugene Aquilina of the Nativity | 1930 |
| 9. | Fr. Redemptus Camilleri of the Cross | 1933 |
| 10. | Fr. Bernard Rigos of the Angels | 1934 |
| 11. | Fr. Angelicus Buttigieg of the Sacred Heart | 1939 |
| 12. | Fr. Bernard Rigos of the Angels | 1944 |
| 13. | Fr. Aloysius Pisani of Christ the King | 1945 |
| 14. | Fr. Angelicus Buttigieg of the Sacred Heart | 1948 |
| 15. | Fr. Eusebio Obezzoni of St Michael | 1950 |
| 16. | Fr. Aloysius Pisani of Christ the King | 1954 |
| 17. | Fr. Angelo Buhagiar of the Blessed Sacrament | 1957 |
| 18. | Fr. Aloysius Pisani of Christ the King | 1960 |
| 19. | Fr. Gabriel Grech of the Incarnation | 1966 |
| 20. | Fr. Aloysius Pisani of Christ the King | 1969 |
| 21. | Fr. Adeodatus Micallef of the Assumption | 1972 |
| 22. | Fr. Aloysius Pisani of Christ the King | 1973 |
| 23. | Fr. Gabriel Grech of the Incarnation | 1978 |
| 24. | Fr. Pius Sammut of the Child Jesus | 1984 |
| 25. | Fr. Gabriel Grech of the Incarnation | 1993 |
| 26. | Fr. Mario Borg of St. Joseph | 1996 |
| 27. | Fr. Alfred Grech of the Good Shepherd | 1999 |
| 28. | Fr. Victor Mallia of the Holy Family | 2005 |
| 29. | Fr. Alfred Grech of the Good Shepherd | 2008 |
| 30. | Fr. Emanuel Schembri of the Mother of God | 2009 |